When to deploy app on BTP and when to deploy on S4HANA on-premise system

Deploy on S/4HANA (On-Premise) → For core ERP processes and apps tightly coupled with SAP transactions. Deploy on SAP BTP → For customer-facing, partner-facing, innovation, and extension apps that should be loosely coupled from the ERP core and scalable to external users. --- 🔹 Example: Tarun’s Paper Product Company 1. Internal / Core Apps → Deployed on S/4HANA On-Premise Example: Production Order Management App for shop floor supervisors. Quality Inspection App for internal inspectors. Goods Movement App for warehouse staff. Why? These are directly dependent on SAP transactions (like `CO01`, `QE51N`, `MIGO`). Used only by internal employees within the firewall. Performance is better since they run close to the ERP database. 👉 These stay inside S/4HANA to avoid latency and ensure system integrity. --- 2. Customer-Facing App → Deployed on BTP Example: Job Tracking App for Tarun’s customers to check order status, delivery date, and invoices. Why? Customers are external users (not S/4 users, no SAP license). App must be accessible over the internet (with proper authentication). Needs scalability (many customers logging in). BTP provides identity authentication (IAS/XSUAA), mobile-ready UI (Fiori/UI5), and API access to S/4 via ODATA/CDS Views. 👉 This app sits on BTP and calls S/4HANA APIs securely. --- 3. Hybrid Case (Mix of Both) Example: Vendor Collaboration App (suppliers upload invoices, check payment status). Backend logic (like invoice posting) still runs in S/4HANA, But the supplier-facing UI + authentication runs on BTP. --- 🔹 Decision Framework (Quick Guide) | Criteria | Deploy on S/4HANA | Deploy on BTP | | ------------------ | -------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- | | User Type | Internal employees | External users (customers, vendors, partners) | | Process Type | Core ERP transactions | Extensions / Innovations | | Licensing | Covered by SAP named users | Cheaper, scalable, no S/4 license for external | | Connectivity | Direct DB access needed | API-based (OData/REST) | | Scalability | Limited to ERP system | Cloud-scale, mobile-ready | | Upgrade Impact | Customization risk | Clean Core safe | --- ✅ In Tarun’s case: Internal apps like production tracking, shop floor reporting → stay in S/4HANA On-Premise. Customer job tracking app → deployed on BTP as an extension, consuming APIs from S/4.

Call us on +91-84484 54549

Mail us on contact@anubhavtrainings.com

Website: Anubhav Online Trainings | UI5, Fiori, S/4HANA Trainings

Comments

Popular posts from this blog